Chicago Inquirer's Logo
BUSINESS
Monday, April 24, 2017


Archive       |     Search This Site
Apple: Samsung deliberately chose to copy iPhone

Apple: Samsung deliberately chose to copy iPhone

by Dan Levine and Poornima Gupta

SAN JOSE, Calif. - Apple Inc told jurors on Tuesday that Samsung's internal documents show it made a decision to copy the iPhone because the South Korean company could not compete in the smartphone market on its own.

However, Samsung Electronics Co Ltd contended that Apple could not claim a "monopoly" over the rectangular design with rounded corners, as it was invented before the iPhone.

"Samsung is not some copyist, some Johnny come lately doing knockoffs," Samsung attorney Charles Verhoeven told the jurors.

Opening statements began on Tuesday in the high profile U.S. trial between Apple and Samsung. Both sides relied on slides featuring various phone models, internal emails and news reports to make their points.

The world's largest consumer electronics corporations have been waging legal war around the world, accusing each other of patent violations as they vie for supremacy in a fast-growing market for mobile devices.

Apple attorney Harold McElhinny started off by showing slides that featured old Samsung phones from 2006 and compared it to the Korean company's newer smartphones from 2010.

The key question, McElhinny said, would be how Samsung moved from the old phones to "these phones." And even though Apple is a successful company, he said, it must defend its rights when someone steals their property.

"Artists don't laugh that often when people steal their designs," McElhinny said.

Samsung attorney Verhoeven countered that many iPhone features, like its popular minimalist design, had already been thought up by others before its release.

"There's a distinction between commercial success and inventing something," Verhoeven said.

Samsung showed slides featuring various mobile device designs prior to the iPhone that had rectangular form factors with rounded corners.

The legal action began last year when Apple sued Samsung in a San Jose, California, federal court, accusing the South Korean company of slavishly copying the iPhone and iPad. Samsung countersued.

The Samsung products at issue run on the Android operating system, which is developed by Google Inc.

McElhinny showed jurors an internal Samsung product analysis which said the iPhone's hardware was "easy to copy." Another document prepared by a Samsung executive said the company was in a "crisis of design" due to the iPhone.

However, Verhoeven said Samsung's analyses were what all companies do in the smartphone industry, including Apple.

Before opening statements began on Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh dismissed one of the jurors, a woman who works as an insurance agent. The woman said her employer would not pay her salary during jury service.

The nine member jury is now made up of seven men and two women.

The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, is Apple Inc v. Samsung Electronics Co Ltd et al, No. 11-1846.

 

Phelps makes history with record 19th medal

LONDON - Michael Phelps won the right to call himself the greatest Olympian of all time when the U.S. team destroyed the field in the 4x200 metres freestyle relay on Tuesday to hand him his 19th medal.

AUSTIN, Texas - Tea Party favorite Ted Cruz scored a stunning upset over a longtime Texas state officeholder in a Republican U.S. Senate primary runoff on Tuesday, transforming Cruz into a national conservative star and marking a resurgence of the movement to shrink the size of U.S. government.

Iconoclastic American author Gore Vidal dead at 86

LOS ANGELES - Writer Gore Vidal, who filled his novels and essays with acerbic observations on politics, sex and American culture while carrying on feuds with big-name literary rivals, died on Tuesday at home in Los Angeles of complications from pneumonia, age 86.

RALEIGH, N.C. - Anand Shimpi is one of the most influential tech industry figures you've never heard of.

Chicago Inquirer Web Poll
Over a year ago, the US predicted that Nigeria will break up in 15 years. Now, the once peaceful Plateau State is in tumor. Is Nigeria moving towards the break up?

Yes
No
Indifferent


                                         

     National   |    Africa   |    US Africa   |    Chicago Metro   |    Business   |    Sports   |    Politics   |    Nation & World   |    Religion   |    Education   |   
Editorial / Op-Ed   |    Point Blank   |    Opinions   |    Letters   |    Arts   |   
Privacy Policy   |    Search   |    Contact Us   |    Work For Us   |    Media Kit    |    Site Map     
xCopyright © Chicago Inquirer. All rights reserved.
Designed and Powered By ChicagoInquirer Inc.